Soy sauce does four jobs at once in a recipe: salt, savory depth, a little sweetness from fermentation, and color. A swap that only adds salt will leave the dish flat, and a swap that only adds color will leave it bland. The seven substitutes below are ordered by how close they land, and every ratio is for 1 tablespoon of soy sauce. Taste after you swap, since brands differ in salt by a wide margin.
In my kitchen, the test that sorts these swaps is a plain stir-fry: the same vegetables, the same pan, only the sauce changed. Tamari came out closest, coconut aminos came out paler and a touch sweet, and fish sauce needed water or it took over the pan. Those three results shape the picker below.

Quick picker: match the substitute to the job
| Substitute | Swap ratio (for 1 Tbsp soy sauce) | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tamari | 1 Tbsp, 1:1 | Everything, the closest swap there is | Slightly less salty, so taste before adding more salt |
| Coconut aminos | 1 Tbsp, 1:1, plus a pinch of salt | Stir-fries, marinades, dipping sauces | Sweeter and paler than soy sauce |
| Fish sauce plus water | 1 tsp fish sauce plus 2 tsp water | Soups, Southeast Asian stir-fries, marinades | Strong aroma when raw, so add it early in cooking |
| Miso paste plus water | 1 tsp miso plus 2 tsp water | Soups, glazes, marinades | Cloudy in clear broths and light sauces |
| Worcestershire sauce | 1 Tbsp, 1:1, plus a pinch of salt | Meat marinades, stews, hearty stir-fries | Tangy and spiced, so skip it in delicate Japanese dishes |
| Liquid aminos | 1 Tbsp, 1:1 | Stir-fries, rice dishes, dressings | Milder and a little sweeter than soy sauce |
| Maggi seasoning plus water | 1 1/2 tsp Maggi plus 1 1/2 tsp water | Soups, stews, fried rice | Very concentrated, so measure it and do not pour freehand |
The seven substitutes, one by one
1. Tamari: the closest swap
Tamari is a Japanese soy sauce made with little or no wheat, so most bottles are gluten-free (check the label if that matters for your table). It swaps 1:1 with soy sauce and brings the same dark color and savory depth, with a slightly smoother, less sharp salt note. It works everywhere soy sauce works, from stir-fries to dipping sauces. For the full rundown on the soy shelf, Soy Sauce Guide: Light vs Dark vs Tamari covers how each bottle behaves.
2. Coconut aminos
Coconut aminos are made from fermented coconut sap and salt, with no soy and no wheat. They swap 1:1 with soy sauce, but they are sweeter and less salty, and they color a dish less. Add a pinch of salt with the swap, and in a stir-fry, let the sauce cook 30 seconds longer so the extra sweetness settles into the pan instead of sitting on top. They suit marinades and dipping sauces well, where the sweetness reads as roundness rather than a flaw.

3. Fish sauce plus water
Fish sauce is saltier and more pungent than soy sauce, so it never swaps 1:1. For 1 tablespoon of soy sauce, use 1 teaspoon of fish sauce plus 2 teaspoons of water, and add it early in cooking so the sharp aroma cooks off and the savory depth stays. It suits soups, Southeast Asian stir-fries, and marinades, where its flavor belongs. It does not suit a plain dipping sauce, where the fish flavor stands out with nothing to hide behind. My Fish Sauce vs Soy Sauce post sorts out when each bottle leads and when it backs up the other.
4. Miso paste plus water
Miso paste is fermented soybean paste, so it shares soy sauce’s savory base. For 1 tablespoon of soy sauce, whisk 1 teaspoon of miso paste with 2 teaspoons of warm water until smooth, then use it as a liquid. White miso is mild and a little sweet, while red miso is stronger and saltier, so pick white miso for light soups and red miso for stews and glazes. The swap turns a clear broth cloudy, so skip it where a clear broth matters, and skip it in a dipping sauce that should stay thin and glossy.
5. Worcestershire sauce
Worcestershire sauce swaps 1:1 with soy sauce in meat dishes, stews, and hearty stir-fries, where its tangy, spiced flavor blends into the background. Add a pinch of salt with it, since it is less salty than soy sauce. It does not suit delicate Japanese dishes, sushi rice, or plain dipping sauces, where its vinegar and spice notes show through. In a marinade for grilled meat, it is a strong pick, and it pairs well with garlic and black pepper.
6. Liquid aminos
Liquid aminos are a non-fermented soy-based seasoning with a taste close to light soy sauce. They swap 1:1 and work well in stir-fries, fried rice, and dressings, where they season without changing the dish’s color much. They are milder and a little sweeter than soy sauce, so in a sauce that should taste dark and salty, add a pinch of salt and taste again. They are a practical bottle to keep when tamari is hard to find.

7. Maggi seasoning plus water
Maggi seasoning is a concentrated wheat-based seasoning with a strong savory flavor, so it never swaps 1:1. For 1 tablespoon of soy sauce, use 1 1/2 teaspoons of Maggi plus 1 1/2 teaspoons of water, and measure both parts. It suits soups, stews, and fried rice, where its depth cooks into the dish. It does not suit a dipping sauce, where its concentrated flavor tastes harsh, and it contains wheat, so it is not a gluten-free pick.
How to swap in four common situations
In a stir-fry (sauce cooked fast over high heat): tamari 1:1 is the cleanest swap, then coconut aminos with a pinch of salt, then liquid aminos. Fish sauce plus water works here too, as long as it goes in early enough to cook off. My Chicken Karaage marinade is the kind of soy-led marinade where tamari swaps in without any other change.
In a marinade (sauce left on meat or tofu for 30 minutes or more): tamari, coconut aminos, and Worcestershire all work, since time lets the flavors settle. Fish sauce plus water works for Southeast Asian marinades. Miso plus water works for a thicker glaze-style marinade that clings to the surface.
In a dipping sauce (sauce served raw, nothing cooked): tamari 1:1 is the only swap that needs no adjustment, and coconut aminos with a pinch of salt is second. Skip fish sauce, miso, and Maggi here, since their flavors are too strong or too cloudy when served raw.
In a soup or noodle broth (sauce diluted in a large pot): fish sauce plus water, miso plus water, and Maggi plus water all work, since the broth gives them room. Tamari and liquid aminos work too. Taste the broth after the swap and salt at the end, since a broth that is salted early is hard to fix later. My Salmon Teriyaki glaze shows the opposite case, a sauce reduced until thick, where only tamari or coconut aminos hold their balance.

What to buy if you buy one bottle
If you buy one substitute bottle, buy tamari. It is the only swap on this list that needs no ratio change, no salt adjustment beyond a taste, and no limits on where it can go. Keep the bottle in the pantry next to the soy sauce, not in the fridge, and check the label for wheat if anyone at your table avoids gluten. A bottle of coconut aminos is the second bottle worth owning, for the weeks when soy is off the table entirely.
More pantry guides to try
Three more from the same shelf: Soy Sauce Guide: Light vs Dark vs Tamari explains the bottle you are replacing; Fish Sauce Substitutes for Every Situation covers the reverse swap; and Oyster Sauce Substitutes for Every Situation sorts out the thick, sweet bottle that often sits beside the soy sauce.