Toasted sesame oil is a finishing oil, not a cooking oil. It is dark, nutty, and strong, pressed from toasted sesame seeds, and it goes into a dish at the end, off the heat, where its aroma can stay in the bowl. One tablespoon is usually enough for a dressing or a noodle bowl for four people. The swaps below are all measured for 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, because that is the amount most recipes call for.
Do not confuse toasted sesame oil with light sesame oil. Light sesame oil is pale and mild, sold for cooking, and it has almost none of the toasted flavor. It can still work as a base in a swap, but on its own it will not replace the flavor you are missing. In my kitchen, the test that sorts these swaps is a plain noodle dressing: the same noodles, the same soy and vinegar, only the oil changed. Perilla oil came out closest, peanut oil with toasted seeds came second, and plain neutral oil on its own came out flat, which is why every seed-based swap below adds the seeds back in.

Quick picker: match the substitute to the job
| Substitute | Swap ratio (for 1 Tbsp toasted sesame oil) | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perilla oil | 1 Tbsp, 1:1 | Everything, the closest swap there is | A little more herbal than sesame, and it goes stale fast |
| Peanut oil plus toasted sesame seeds | 1 Tbsp peanut oil plus 1 tsp toasted sesame seeds | Noodle bowls, dressings, stir-fry finishes | Peanut flavor shows through, so skip it for peanut allergies |
| Neutral oil plus toasted sesame seeds | 1 Tbsp neutral oil plus 1 tsp toasted sesame seeds | Any dish, when peanuts are off the table | Seeds need toasting first, or the swap tastes flat |
| Light sesame oil plus toasted sesame seeds | 1 Tbsp light sesame oil plus 1 tsp toasted sesame seeds | Dressings and noodle bowls | Still milder than toasted oil, so taste before serving |
| Tahini plus neutral oil | 1 tsp tahini plus 2 tsp neutral oil | Creamy dressings and noodle sauces | Thick and cloudy, so skip it in clear soups and light dressings |
| Walnut oil | 1 Tbsp, 1:1 | Cold dressings and noodle salads | Mild and pricey, and it must stay off the heat |
| Chili oil plus neutral oil | 1 tsp chili oil plus 2 tsp neutral oil | Spicy noodle bowls and dumpling sauces only | Adds heat, so it fits only where heat belongs |
The seven substitutes, one by one
1. Perilla oil: the closest swap
Perilla oil is pressed from perilla seeds, a Korean pantry staple, and it swaps 1:1 with toasted sesame oil. It is nutty like sesame oil, with a slightly herbal edge that suits Korean noodle bowls and lettuce wraps well. It is also a finishing oil, so add it off the heat, the same way you would add sesame oil. Keep it in the fridge and use it within a few months, since it turns stale faster than most oils. For how toasted sesame oil itself behaves over heat, How to Use Toasted Sesame Oil Without Burning It covers the heat limits that apply to perilla oil too.
2. Peanut oil plus toasted sesame seeds
When perilla oil is not on the shelf, this is the swap I reach for most. For 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, use 1 tablespoon of peanut oil plus 1 teaspoon of toasted sesame seeds, crushed lightly between your fingers so they release their aroma. Peanut oil is neutral enough to carry the seeds, and the seeds supply the toasted note that plain oil lacks. It works in noodle bowls, dressings, and stir-fry finishes. It does not work for a peanut allergy, and it does not work where sesame itself is the allergy, since the seeds are still sesame.
3. Neutral oil plus toasted sesame seeds
This is the same idea without the peanut flavor. For 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, use 1 tablespoon of a neutral oil, such as grapeseed or sunflower oil, plus 1 teaspoon of toasted sesame seeds. Toast the seeds first in a dry pan over medium heat for 2 to 3 minutes, shaking the pan, until they turn golden and smell nutty. Raw seeds will not do the job. Let the seeds cool, crush them lightly, and stir them into the oil. This swap suits any dish on the list, and it costs almost nothing if you already keep sesame seeds for topping.

4. Light sesame oil plus toasted sesame seeds
If you have light sesame oil but not toasted, add the toasted note back in the same way. For 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, use 1 tablespoon of light sesame oil plus 1 teaspoon of toasted sesame seeds, toasted and crushed as above. The base oil is already sesame, so the swap lands a little closer than a neutral oil does, though it still reads milder than true toasted oil. Taste the dressing before serving and add a few more crushed seeds if the nutty note is still faint. This swap is a good fit for dressings and noodle bowls, where the oil is tasted directly.
5. Tahini plus neutral oil
Tahini is ground sesame paste, so it carries the same toasted flavor in a thicker form. For 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, whisk 1 teaspoon of tahini with 2 teaspoons of neutral oil until smooth, then use the mix as a liquid. It suits creamy dressings and noodle sauces, where its body blends in, and it thickens a sauce in a pleasant way. It does not suit clear soups, light vinaigrettes, or any dish where the oil should stay thin and clear, since tahini turns the liquid cloudy. It also does not work for a sesame allergy, since tahini is sesame.

6. Walnut oil
Walnut oil swaps 1:1 with toasted sesame oil and brings a mild, nutty flavor that works well in cold dressings and noodle salads. It is gentler than sesame oil, so in a dish where sesame oil leads, such as a sesame noodle dressing, use the full tablespoon and taste, then add a pinch of toasted sesame seeds if you want a stronger toasted note. Like perilla oil, walnut oil is a finishing oil: keep it off the heat and store it in the fridge, since nut oils turn stale faster than neutral oils. It is pricey, so save it for cold dishes where its flavor is tasted directly.
7. Chili oil plus neutral oil
Chili oil is a swap only for dishes that want heat. For 1 tablespoon of toasted sesame oil, use 1 teaspoon of chili oil plus 2 teaspoons of neutral oil, which keeps the heat in check while still giving a warm, savory note. It suits spicy noodle bowls and dumpling dipping sauces, where chili flavor belongs. It does not suit a plain sesame dressing, a mild soup, or any dish served to people who avoid spice, since the heat will stand out with nothing to hide behind. If the chili oil you have is sesame-based, it already carries some of the flavor you are replacing, and the swap lands closer.
How to swap in four common situations
In a dressing or noodle bowl (oil served raw, nothing cooked): perilla oil 1:1 is the cleanest swap, then peanut oil with toasted seeds, then light sesame oil with toasted seeds. Tahini plus neutral oil works here too, but only in a creamy dressing. Skip chili oil here unless the bowl is meant to be spicy. My Soba Noodle Salad with Sesame Dressing is the kind of cold noodle bowl where perilla oil swaps in without any other change.
In a stir-fry finish (oil added at the end, off the heat): any 1:1 swap works, and any seed-based swap works too, since the hot pan wakes up the toasted seeds. Add the oil after the pan comes off the heat, toss once, and serve, since a minute on high heat will dull the nutty aroma. For the heat rules behind that timing, How to Use Toasted Sesame Oil Without Burning It explains why finishing oils stay off the flame.

In a marinade (oil left on meat or tofu for 30 minutes or more): perilla oil, peanut oil with seeds, and light sesame oil with seeds all work, since time lets the flavors settle. Tahini plus neutral oil works for a thicker marinade that clings to the surface, such as a noodle-bowl protein marinade. Walnut oil is a weaker pick here, since its mild flavor gets lost during a long marinade.
In a soup finish (oil drizzled over a hot bowl at the table): perilla oil and walnut oil are the best picks, since they stay clear and aromatic on a hot surface. Seed-based swaps work too, as long as the seeds are crushed fine, so they do not sit on the soup as grit. Skip tahini here, since it clouds the broth, and skip chili oil unless the soup is meant to be spicy.
What to buy if you buy one bottle
If you buy one substitute bottle, buy perilla oil, if you cook Korean food often. It is the only swap on this list that needs no ratio change and no extra step, and it keeps well in the fridge for the months a small bottle lasts. If Korean cooking is rare at your table, skip the extra bottle and keep toasted sesame seeds instead: a bag of seeds plus a neutral oil you already own covers most of these swaps, and the seeds also top noodle bowls, salads, and stir-fries on their own.
More pantry guides to try
Three more from the same shelf: How to Use Toasted Sesame Oil Without Burning It explains the bottle you are replacing; Soy Sauce Substitutes for Every Situation covers the other bottle that usually sits beside it; and Oyster Sauce Substitutes for Every Situation sorts out the thick, sweet bottle that often joins both in a stir-fry sauce.